Wikipedia:Interwiki linking conflicts

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This Wikipedia page is currently inactive and is retained as a historical archive.
Either the page is no longer relevant or consensus has become unclear. If you want to revive discussion regarding the subject, you should seek broader input via a forum such as the proposals page of the village pump.

This page is about conflicting Wikipedia links between articles in different languages.

1 Related pages
2 Why a "stealth" template?
- 2.1 Specifying details
- 2.2 Examples
3 Other reasons causing conflicts
4 Hints for solving a conflict
5 Interlanguage coordination
- 5.1 meta:pyWikipediaBot
- 5.2 Participating Wikipedias
  - 5.2.1 GlobalWPSearch
6 See also

[edit] Related pages

[edit] Why a "stealth" template?

Template:Interwikiconflict is a "stealth" template. It does not insert visible characters in a page but can be detected with Special:Whatlinkshere/Template:Interwikiconflict.
Many templates with the visible text "You can help ..." relate to issues which can be solved by everybody.
Conflicts in interlanguage links can have many reasons, often more then a dozen of languages using different alphabets are involved. At least in one of the languages two titles link from one language link directly or over a chain of links to the same title in another language. This is why such conflicts should be solved only with a minimum knowledge of the involved languages. It is not enough to link articles with identical titles / with transcripted variants of the same titles.
Often some of the involved pages link to a disambiguation page in a particular language and other "of the same set" to a particular meaning specified in this disambiguation. Somtimes it happens that in one of the languages the content of a disambiguation page is swapped with or redirected to the "primary title" but existing interlanguage links are not adjusted, people do not know about interlanguage links from other languages pointing to "their" articled. See examples below.

If there is no conflict in interlanguage links bots can easily add interlanguage links and correct / readjust redirects, delete links to nonexisting pages, substitute various types of encoding, obey to special conventions about

the order (alphabeticaly by "wiki" code / by the expaned name of those languages),
the place (top / bottom inside the page source)
the format (one per line / separated with only one space)

of the interlanguage links. This is why a conflict locks the insertion of interlanguage links for the whole set of titles / the insertion in all languages involved.
Such conflicts are detected by many bots. If they are not fixed bots will download the involved pages over and over again causing unnecessary server load.

[edit] Specifying details

It is possible to insert explanatory information in the template, for example: {{interwikiconflict|Duplicate articles: [[:nl:Odin]] — [[:nl:Wodan]]}}. Hopefully this information would be displayed in GlobalWPSearch.^[clarify]

[edit] Examples

Typical examples are states having the same name as their capital, island states, chemical elements etc.:

Luxembourg [1], Monaco [2]
Cyprus [3], England [4], Ireland [5], Iceland [6], Malta [7]
See: de:Spezial:Allpages/Malta, de:Malta (Begriffsklärung) (disambiguation), de:Malta, de:Malta (Insel), de:Malta (Fluss)
Mercury [8], Titan [9]

[edit] Ask and Embla

en:Ask and Embla (GlobalWPSearch Ask and Embla — GlobalWPSearch Ask og Embla) is one title in many Wikipedias
nevertheless there are Wikipedias where Ask GlobalWPSearch Ask is an extra title and Embla GlobalWPSearch Embla also.

[edit] eo:Aborigeno and eo:Aborigenoj de Aŭstralio

solved
Both articles have been linked to de:Aborigine, en:Australian Aborigine, fi:Aboriginaali, fr:Aborigènes d'Australie, he:אבוריג'ינים, it:Aborigeni australiani, ja:アボリジニ, nl:Aboriginals, pl:Aborygeni, ru:Абориген.
In a first step it was clear, that all articlis except ru:Абориген relate to eo:Aborigenoj de Aŭstralio. The eo: link has been corrected in all these articles except the russian.
With my minimal knowledge of Russian I was not 100% shure if ru:Абориген should link to eo:Aborigeno or not. This is why I have included {{interwikiconflict}} in these two titles.
In a next step I can contact friends from ru: and ask for help. I can let a note at eo:Talk:Aborigeno and ru:Talk:Абориген.
If a Bot runs over this sequence he will detect the conflict. Nevertheless now there is a indication, that this conflict is already known and some actions at the Wikipedias xx, yy etc. need to be made.
Regards Gangleri | Th | T 20:14, 2005 Mar 15 (UTC)

Wrong Russian interwikies are removed. MaxiMaxiMax 03:09, 16 Mar 2005 (UTC)

Thanks MaxiMaxiMax! It seams that this method could work! Gangleri | Th | T 08:20, 2005 Mar 16 (UTC)

[edit] ru:Хазары and ru:Хазарский каганат

solved
Both titles are linked to a subset of bg:Хазари, de:Chasaren, en:Khazars, fi:Kasaarit, fr:Khazars, he:ממלכת הכוזרים, it:Khazary, lt:Chazarai, pl:Chazarowie, ro:Chazari, tt:Xäzärlär etc. Solving this will require skills in many languages in order to compare the content of these titles.

All this articles correspond to ru:Хазары and only en:Khazars have data that corresponds both ru:Хазары and ru:Хазарский каганат, so I preferred to remove all interwiki links to ru:Хазарский каганат (Khazar state) and leave only links to ru:Хазары (Khazar people). MaxiMaxiMax 10:44, 16 Mar 2005 (UTC)

but the bg: and he: are about the state and not about the people. conio.h • talk 15:07, 21 April 2006 (UTC)

[edit] eo:-23 eo:-22 eo:-21 eo:-20 etc.

solved
See eo:Speciala:Contributions/Quistnix from 20. Mar 2005. Dozens of titles where linking via ja:紀元前1世紀 to en:1st century BC.
Thanks Quistnix! Regards Gangleri | Th | T 19:16, 2005 Mar 21 (UTC)

[edit] nl:Paris — nl:Paris (mythologie) — nl:Parijs

To my opinion all of the titles linked directly or over a chain of interlanguage links to the titles above should be grouped in (at least) three groops:

those containig an equivalent of Template:Disambig should link to nl:Paris
af:Paris als:Paris da:Paris (flertydig) de:Paris (Begriffsklärung) en:Paris (disambiguation) fr:Paris (homonymie) nl:Paris sv:Paris (olika betydelser)
content related — link to nl:Paris (mythologie)
ca:Paris da:Prins Paris de:Paris (Mythologie) en:Paris (mythology) es:Paris fr:Pâris he:פאריס (מיתולוגיה) hr:Paris it:Paride ja:パリス ko:파리 시 nl:Paris (mythologie) pt:Páris sv:Paris (mytologi)
content related — link to nl:Parijs
af:Parys als:Paris (Stadt) bg:Париж ca:París cs:Paříž cy:Paris da:Paris de:Paris en:Paris eo:Paris -> eo:Parizo es:París et:Pariis fi:Pariisi fr:Paris gl:París - Paris he:פריז id:Paris io:Paris it:Paris -> it:Parigi ja:パリ kn:ಪ್ಯಾರಿಸ್ ko:파리 시 la:Paris -> la:Lutetia lb:Paräis li:Paries lt:Paryžius lv:Parīze na:Paris nb:Paris nds:Paris nl:Parijs nn:Paris pl:Paryż pt:Paris ro:Paris ru:Париж simple:Paris sl:Pariz sr:Париз sv:Paris ta:பாரிஸ் tr:Paris uk:Париж vi:Paris zh:巴黎 — note: verified by ro:User:MihaitzaBot — Gangleri | Th | T 20:04, 2005 Apr 6 (UTC)

The main problem I can see is when languages are involved I have no clue about ja:, zh:, ko:, vi:, fi:, ar:, fa: etc. and I do not now Wikipedians from that Wikipedia. Hopefully we can make an international team to handle this. Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 11:15, 2005 Apr 5 (UTC)

Note: At the moment GlobalWPSearch searchs only for identical titles. Only if there is a redirect / are redirects as

GlobalWPSearch will "follow and find" the article(s) "trought" the redirect(s). To see this please make a redirect from lb:Paris to lb:Paräis and tray again GlobalWPSearch Paris.
For places many Wikipedias are using the "oficial" names. If there are common names redirects from the original names to the one used in the language of the Wikipedia are mad.
This is common standard at many Wikipedias

Please consider to have such redirects at "your Wikipedia" as well. Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 19:20, 2005 Apr 19 (UTC)

[edit] Duplicate articles: nl:Odin — nl:Wodan

en:Odin

solved
See nl:Wikipedia:Duplicaten#O — Gangleri | Th | T 11:20, 2005 Apr 5 (UTC)

{{interwikiconflict|Duplicate articles: [[:nl:Odin]] — [[:nl:Wodan]]}} was inserted (only) at:
nl:Odin — nl:Wodan, da:Odin, de:Odin, en:Odin, nb:Odin, pt:Odin, sv:Oden
other languages: ang:Wóden ca:Odín da:Odin de:Odin en:Odin eo:Odino es:Odín fi:Odin fr:Odin it:Odino ja:オーディン nb:Odin nn:Odin pl:Odyn pt:Odin ro:Odin sv:Oden zh:奥丁
Regards Gangleri | Th | T 13:59, 2005 Apr 9 (UTC)

After informations within the Dutch community the common opinion is that both articles nl:Wodan and nl:Odin should remain because there is a subtle difference between the two Gods. So I will try to link all Odin articles to the nl:Odin article, vice versa the Wodan articles. Ellywa 18:26, 16 Apr 2005 (UTC)

Now the interlanguage links are as follows:

nl:Wodan == ang:Wóden
nl:Odin == ca:Odín, da:Odin, de:Odin, en:Odin, eo:Odino, es:Odín, fi:Odin, fr:Odin, it:Odino, ja:オーディン, nb:Odin, nl:Odin, nn:Odin, pl:Odyn, pt:Odin, ro:Odin, sv:Oden, zh:奥丁

All templates "interwikiconflict" have been removed. See: GlobalWPSearch Odin. Regards Gangleri | Th | T 05:29, 2005 Apr 17 (UTC)

[edit] some titles named Valencia

solved

disambiguation pages: de:Valencia de:Valencia:, en:Valencia (disambiguation), eo:Valencio, es:Valencia, fr:Valencia, nl:Valencia, ja:バレンシア, pl:Walencja
city of Spain: ca:València, de:València, en:Valencia, es:Valencia (España), fi:Valencia, fr:Valence (Espagne), it:Valencia, nl:Valencia (stad), sv:Valencia, tr:Valencia, zh:巴倫西亞 — et:Valencia, pl:Walencja (miasto)
city of Venezuela: af:Valencia, Venezuela, de:Valencia (Venezuela), en:Valencia, Venezuela, es:Valencia (Venezuela), fr:Valencia (Venezuela), ja:バレンシア (ベネズエラ), nl:Valencia (Venezuela), pt:Valência (Venezuela)
football club: de:FC Valencia, en:Valencia CF, es:Valencia CF, pl:Valencia CF

~~There is a "interwikiconflict at et:Valencia.~~ Regards Gangleri | Th | T 15:07, 2005 Apr 11 (UTC)
- Is in order now: about the city in Spain. Andres 20:07, 11 Apr 2005 (UTC)

Thanks Andres! Regards Gangleri | Th | T 21:45, 2005 Apr 12 (UTC)

- fixed in af: (there article was in double, once as "Valencia" and once as "Valencia, Venezuela", I redirected links to "Valencia, Venezuela" and made "Valencia" a dismabig page)
- fixed in the list the name of the football club page for pl: Srtxg 22:31, 10 November 2005 (UTC)

[edit] some titles named Toledo

disambiguation pages: de:Toledo, en:Toledo (disambiguation), eo:Toledo, fr:Toledo, it:Toledo, nl:Toledo, pl:Toledo, pt:Toledo (desambiguação)
ca:Toledo, de:Toledo (Spanien), en:Toledo, eo:Toledo (Hispanio), es:Toledo, fr:Tolède, gl:Toledo, it:Toledo (Spagna), ja:トレド, nl:Toledo (Spanje), pl:Toledo (Hiszpania), pt:Toledo (Espanha), ro:Toledo, sv:Toledo

If you look at the content of sv:Toledo you will see that at the moment (18:49, 2005 Apr 11 (UTC)) this page should link to the "disambiguation pages". I inserted sv:Mall:Disambig but did not link to the en:Toledo (disambiguation) chain.

History of a interwikiconflict:

probably at some point in time pt:Toledo was the only article at pt:
http://pt.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Toledo&action=history
pt:Toledo was moved to pt:Toledo (Espanha) and pt:Toledo redirected to pt:Toledo (desambiguação)
the interlanguage links have not been fixed. Quite simple

Regards Gangleri | Th | T 18:49, 2005 Apr 11 (UTC)

[edit] disambiguation it:Giovanni Agnelli — it:Giovanni Agnelli (senior) — it:Gianni Agnelli

solved

disambiguation page: it:Giovanni Agnelli
en:Giovanni Agnelli, eo:Giovanni Agnelli ->eo:Giovanni AGNELLI, es:Giovanni Agnelli, fi:Giovanni Agnelli, it:Giovanni Agnelli (senior)
en:Gianni Agnelli, de:Giovanni Agnelli, fi:Gianni Agnelli, fr:Gianni Agnelli, it:Gianni Agnelli, nl:Gianni Agnelli

See: GlobalWPSearch Giovanni Agnelli Regards Gangleri | Th | T 15:26, 2005 Apr 14 (UTC)

[edit] en:Francis Bacon (disambiguation) — en:Francis Bacon philosopher, statesman and essayist — en:Francis Bacon (painter)

solved

disambiguation pages: en:Francis Bacon (disambiguation), fr:Francis Bacon, it:Francis Bacon, ja:フランシス・ベーコン, nl:Francis Bacon, pl:Francis Bacon, pt:Francis Bacon
bn:ফ্রান্সিস বেকন, de:Francis Bacon, en:Francis Bacon, eo:Francis Bacon -> eo:Francis BACON, es:Francis Bacon, et:Francis Bacon, fi:Francis Bacon, fr:Francis Bacon (philosophe), it:Francesco Bacone, ja:フランシス・ベーコン (哲学者), nl:Francis Bacon (wetenschapper), pl:Francis Bacon (filozof), pt:Francis Bacon (filósofo), ru:Бэкон, Фрэнсис, sk:Francis Bacon, sl:Francis Bacon, sr:Френсис Бекон, sv:Francis Bacon, tr:Sir Francis Bacon, zh:弗兰西斯·培根
de:Francis Bacon (Maler), en:Francis Bacon (painter), fi:Francis Bacon (maalari), fr:Francis Bacon (peintre), pl:Francis Bacon (malarz), pt:Francis Bacon (artista), ru:Бэкон, Фрэнсис (Художник), tr:Francis Bacon

See some history of disambiguation pages. Before they where still linked to normal articles: pt, ja Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 23:18, 2005 Apr 14 (UTC)

[edit] en:Michael Collins — en:Michael Collins (astronaut) — en:Michael Collins (Irish leader)

solved

See: GlobalWPSearch Michael Collins — Regards Gangleri | Th | T 10:19, 2005 Apr 16 (UTC)

[edit] en:Alexandre Dumas — en:Alexandre Dumas, père — en:Alexandre Dumas, fils

solved

See: GlobalWPSearch Alexandre Dumas — Regards Gangleri | Th | T 17:00, 2005 Apr 16 (UTC)

[edit] en:Wikipedia:Embassy and en:Wikipedia:Village pump

en:Hot pot

Some Wikipedias where using the same page as "village pump" and as "embassy" causing conflicts. Normaly only one page from one Wikipedia should link to a page from another Wikipedia.
All "village pump" pages have been removed from the "chain" linking to en:Wikipedia:Embassy. The corresponding Wikipedias where informed / will be informed about this and many new "embassy" pages have been made. Regards Gangleri | Th | T 14:45, 2005 Apr 21 (UTC)

Now (05:10, 2005 Apr 23 (UTC)) there should be no conflicts between interlanguage links for the pages linked "from" en:Wikipedia:Village pump. However there maigt be pages in other Wikipedias or in the Wikipedias linked to en:Wikipedia:Village pump which link also "to" this chain but not viceversa. The consistency of the links from such "to me unknow" pages could not be verified.
Some Wikipedias are placing the interlanguage links in templates. As soon as the template is used in another page then the ones already linked together conflicts will occur. This maight stop bots maintainig (expanding / adding new languages, updateing redirects because of changes in namespaces etc.) the list(s).
All pages from other namespaces as the "project namespace" linked to the chains mentioned above have been removed. Gangleri | Th | T 05:10, 2005 Apr 23 (UTC)

See also: meta:Wikimedia Embassy

At [[:en:]] there are two / more pages about embassies:
1. en:Wikipedia:Embassy — other languages link here
2. en:Wikipedia:Local Embassy
At fr: there are two / more pages about embassies:
1. fr:Wikipédia:Diplomatie internationale
2. fr:Wikipédia:Ambassade — other languages link here

Question:

How these pages should be linked to the other languages? Regards Gangleri | Th | T 14:32, 2005 Apr 21 (UTC)

Answers:

...

[edit] some titles named Luxembourg — Luxemburg

solved
Note: redirects named Luxembourg — Luxemburg are not listed

Regards Gangleri | Th | T 20:04, 2005 Apr 20 (UTC)

[edit] Amphion and Zethus or Amphion and Zethus ?

Need split this article or merge articles in other wikipedias:

en:Amphion and Zethus
pl:Amfion i Zetos
de:Amphion and "Zethos" (in future)
fr:Amphion and fr:Zéthos
gl:Anfión and "Zeto" (in future)
it:Anfion and it:Zeto
ru:Зеф and "Амфион" (in future)

--Kaganer 10:15, 2 December 2005 (UTC)

[edit] Other reasons causing conflicts

In one of the languages involved there are two aricles for the same "correct" title. They may differentiate because:

of only one character written upper / lower case
one of the titles having an addition
both titles written differently but relating to the same content
in the help or project namespace it may happen that a reference to another language is not referenced "inline" (with a ":" before the "language prfefix"); this way extra interlanguage links without any relation to that page will be generated;

[edit] Hints for solving a conflict

For every title it maight be a good idea to search with links like

for "candidates" to replace the existing title.
...

[edit] Interlanguage coordination

This template should be available in as many languages as possible, one could use a redirect from a spelling (literation in another alphabets) to the "Template:Interwikiconflict form". So both zh:Template:Interwikiconflict and zh:Special:Whatlinkshere/Template:Interwikiconflict should be available.
A "report" of the conflict should be available at the discussion page of one of the languages. At the start of this reports shold be an indications about

the "status" of the conflict: open / solved / fixed live
a timestamp
other informations: who has reported the conflict, who has solved it partialy, pending / waiting for "language code" etc.

In other involved Wikipedias there should be a link to that location.

[edit] meta:pyWikipediaBot

Once a conflict is solved a bot should fix links in all involved languages (if none of the databases is locked). The status should change then to "fixed live".

[edit] Participating Wikipedias

commons: Template:Interwikiconflict, Special:Whatlinkshere/Template:Interwikiconflict

See also:

GlobalWPSearch &search=Template:Interwikiconflict

[edit] GlobalWPSearch

GlobalWPSearch is a tool developed by de:Benutzer:Aka. It helps to identify titles with the same name, lists missing interlanguage links and supports now up to 50 languages.
It identifies known equivalents of

It is planed to identify also equivalents of Template:Delete and Template:Copyvio and their variants.
Please note that titles may relate to different issues. Examples:

en:Island =/= de:Island
en:Hunt =/= de:Hunt =/= (et:Hunt == en:Wolf)
GlobalWPSearch Boxer - different meanings
See: en:Special:Allpages/George Herbert
(en:George Herbert == eo:George Herbert -> eo:George HERBERT) =/= (it:George Herbert == en:George Herbert, 5th Earl of Carnarvon)
Either en:George Herbert or en:George Herbert (disambiguation) should be a disambiguation page. Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 08:16, 2005 Apr 16 (UTC)
(de:Heinrich Hoffmann == eo:Heinrich Hoffmann -> eo:Heinrich HOFFMANN) =/= sv:Heinrich Hoffmann
en:John Buchanan =/= eo:John Buchanan -> eo:John BUCHANAN
See: en:Special:Allpages/Robert Cecil
en:Robert Cecil -> en:Robert Cecil, 1st Earl of Salisbury =/= (en:Robert Cecil, 1st Viscount Cecil of Chelwood, en:Robert Cecil -> eo:Robert CECIL, es:Robert Cecil)
Either en:Robert Cecil or en:Robert Cecil (disambiguation) should be a disambiguation page. Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 08:16, 2005 Apr 16 (UTC)

At the moment GlobalWPSarch GlobalWPSearch Island does not indicate this. However GlobalWPSearch is continuously improuved and implementation of new features is just a mather of develpoment and server resources.
- We are searching translations of "MediaWiki $wgMagicWords" at various wiki's:
  - list of equivalents for REDIRECT - MAG_REDIRECT
- We are searching templates at various wiki's:
GlobalWPSearch is restricted to Wikipedias based on latin alphabet. GlobalWPSearch is not a bot. An aproach to find the interlanguage links from Wikipedias based on other alphabets maight be to look in the GlobalWPSearch list at titles recently modified by bots. In these titles the interlanguage links should be "up to date" but will not include "isolated" titles. Lists of bots can be found following interlanguage links from en:Wikipedia:Bots and en:Category:Wikipedia bots.
More informations soon. Best regards Gangleri | Th | T 07:33, 2005 Apr 11 (UTC)

[edit] See also

User:GangleriBot/InterWiki/ambiguities 01 – Now (13:13, 2005 Mar 6 UTC) there are more then 200 conflicts waiting documentation and fixing.

See also ebooksgratis.com: no banners, no cookies, totally FREE.