Talk:List of vineyards and wineries
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
This list of wineries can never be complete - should the page just be removed? Perhaps best to reference some outside sources (www.wineontheweb.com or Wine-Searcher).
Remove long block of text inserted to promote Candadian wines with little other perceived purpose Steve.Moulding 20:52, 29 January 2007 (UTC)
What's with all the spam to the wine competition pages. Shouldn't a list be just a list? Are the wine competition links so important that they belong next to the names of each estate on the list? There are numerous facts that would be more significant to add along side the list if this is to be anything other than an index of links to wine estates on wikipedia. - Mikecase00 2006-05-22
What's the point of this page? If it's non-exhaustive, then on what basis are some names here and others not; and it it were to be completed (however unlikely that is) it would be of inordinate length and hardly illuminating. Plus there are errors in it, even at the small size it is now - eg Meursault Charmes Roulot is neither a vineyard nor a winery, but rather a wine made by a producer (whose name is Roulot), from a vineyard (whose names is Charmes). I'd recommend it just gets deleted, but don't know wikipedia procedure for sorting that out --Nickhh 19:24, 15 May 2007 (UTC)
This list is utterly pointless and useless, and should be trashed asap. As the very least, such a list should be sorted by types of wine and geographic region. But because such a list is merely the tip of a huge iceberg, and notoriously outdated, I think that categories will always do a better job. --Tetris L (talk) 12:02, 17 January 2008 (UTC)
