Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/B. Scott

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Do Not Delete: B.Scott is making revolutionary moves within the entertainment industry by using YouTube as a mechanism to change the life of his fans by sharing his own experiences and advice. He is a noted entertainment host and has been featured for entertainment contributions in national publications (See, Clik magazine this month) for a recent view. As a gay entertainer, B.Scott is not only notable but he is necessary. Just because he has not been relevant for you, does not mean his is not relevant to the world. Check your sources. Blaackstarr (talk) 05:17, 24 January 2008 (UTC)

Contents 1 Independent administrator's closing analysis 1.1 Raw count analysis 1.2 Valid keep arguments 1.3 Discounted keep arguments 1.4 Valid Delete Arguments 1.5 Summary

[edit] Independent administrator's closing analysis

If you choose to add comments to this page, please do so in a new section below, do not inturrupt my comments here.

[edit] Raw count analysis

• Delete

1. Aecis (edits=8) <nominator>
2. Merovingian (edits=2)
3. SatyrTN (edits=1)
4. TJ Spyke (edits=3)
5. Wwwwolf (edits=5)
6. Yngvarr (edits=9)
7. Truco9311 (edits=3)
8. LAX (edits=2)
9. Doctorfluffy (edits=1)
10. Accounting4Taste (edits=7)
11. Mandsford (edits=1)

• Keep

1. The Transhumanist (edits=1)
2. DGG (edits=1)
3. Lrprice (edits=4)
4. 82.46.205.207 (edits=1)

• Non-participatory

1. SineBot (edits=9) - doing that whole sinebot thing
2. WebHamster (edits=1) - added SPA notices
3. Redfarmer (edits=1) - added SPA notice
4. Keeper76 (2 edits) - closed the debate
5. 12 Noon (edits=1) - added SPA notice

• Single-purpose accounts and/or suspected sockpuppets

1. Blaackstarr (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
2. Coolbeans1981 (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
3. 70.226.4.203 (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
4. Dennsifan (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
5. Ytfamilia (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
6. Simply lysha (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
7. Tlt02k (talk • contribs • count) (edits=5)
8. TinnyLOVE (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
9. Sdotty313 (talk • contribs • count) (edits=1)
10. MissPrettyncurvy (talk • contribs • count) (edits=3)

[edit] Valid keep arguments

• 6 reliable sources
  • featured in "Clik Magazine", the largest Black Gay & Lesbian Monthly publication in the United States that has over 100,000 readers
  • Wire Image reference valid
  • The Jamaican Observer reference valid
  • The Daily Tar Heel reference valid
• encyclopedic content
• Youtube overall statistics are validation for 'popularity and 'recognition'
  • among the top 100 most viewed youtubers
• If the highest-grossing movies produced in Hollywood are notable --> the most watched ones on youtube are

[edit] Discounted keep arguments

• WP:ILIKEIT
• WP:OSE
• gay, multi-racial, creates non-biased media
• not just blogger; also actor, activist and host
• HIV positive

[edit] Valid Delete Arguments

• insufficient assertion of notability
• non-notable
• no reliable sources
• self-publication
• WP:SPAM
• very low ghits

[edit] Summary

This discussion generated a lot of valuable context that can be used to revise WP:N. I encourage those who made valid keep arguments about youtube status being important to please take this issue up at the appropriate venue (village pump or WT:NN?). But as for this AfD, there was clear consensus for delete, once the SPA and devalued comments were duly ignored. JERRY ^talk _contribs 20:59, 2 February 2008 (UTC)