Al Qaida guest house, Faisalabad

10016

• American intelligence analysts assert he is a top member of the al Qaeda leadership.
• Some skeptics assert that he was mentally unstable, and had less serious responsibilities the American intelligence community asserts.
• Was held, until the fall of 2006, in the CIA's archipelago of covert interrogation centres, known as the black sites.
• Was transferred to military custody at Guantanamo in the fall of 2006, with thirteen other "high value detainees".
• The Bush administration announced plans for Abu Zubaydah and the other thirteen "high value detainees" to face charges before military commissions.
• The DoD has not convened a Competent Tribunal, to determine whether Abu Zubaydah has broken the laws of war, so that he is not entitled to the protections of Prisoner of War status, which many legal scholars argue the USA is obliged to do, to fulfill its responsibilities as a signatory of the Geneva Conventions.
• The DoD has not convened a Combatant Status Review Tribunal, to determine whether or not Abu Zubaydah should be classified as an enemy combatant.
• A May 28, 2008 article in the Hindustan Times reported the safehouse was a Lashkar-e-Toiba safehouse.^[1]

696

• Said to be one of Abu Zubaydah's lieutenants.
• Charged in November 2005, before a military commission, including conspiracy to murder.
• His status was considered by a Combatant Status Review Tribunal, but he chose not to participate.
• Argued that he should be allowed to defend himself.

694

• Said to be one of Abu Zubaydah's lieutenants.
• Charged in November 2005, before a military commission, including conspiracy to murder.
• His status was considered by a Combatant Status Review Tribunal, which he attended.
• Argued that he should be allowed to defend himself.

682

• Said to be one of Abu Zubaydah's lieutenants.
• Charged in November 2005, before a military commission, including conspiracy to murder.
• His status was considered by a Combatant Status Review Tribunal, which he attended, but used as a forum to denounce the USA.
• Argued that he should be allowed to defend himself.

753

• Not alleged to be part of Abu Zubaydah's entourage.
• Alleged to have played a part in the wounding, via hand grenade, of a Canadian journalist.
• His status was considered by a Combatant Status Review Tribunal, which he attended.

703

• Was billeted in Abu Zubaydah's safe house by accident. He should have been billeted in the Yemeni House.
• Had lived for much of the 1990s in Europe, where he was a drug dealer and pickpocket.
• Had agreed to go to Afghanistan, prior to September 11, 2001, ostensibly for military training. But his real plan was to purchase heroin to sell when he returned to Europe. A kilo of Heroin could be sold for almost fifty times more in Europe than it cost in Afghanistan.

& id

690

• The allegations against Qader don't say he was captured in a safe house, merely that he was captured in Faisalabad.^[2]
• However, during Al Zarnuki's Tribunal it was stated that Al Zarnuki, Mohammed Mohammed Hassen were all apprehended at the same time, and the allegations in Hassen's transcript say he was captured in the Crescent Mill guesthouse.
• Al Zarnuki said he and eleven others were captured in Salafi University's foreign student's dormitory.

691

• Alleged to have been captured with thirteen other foreigners.^[3]
• Al Zarnuki claimed that he and the other captive apprehended with him were all foreign students living in the foreign student's dormitory.
• Al Zarnuki denied ever traveling to Afghanistan.
• Al Zarnuki called Mohammed Mohammed Hassen and Ahmed Abdul Qader as witnesses -- fellow Yemenis who were captured with him.
• The allegations against Mohammed Mohammed Hassen said he was captured in the "Cresent Mill guesthouse".

681

• Al Zarnuki's testimony says ^[4]
• The allegations against Mohammed Mohammed Hassen said he was captured in the "Cresent Mill guesthouse".
• However Mohammed Ali Salem Al Zarnuki's transcript makes clear that he was captured with Al Zarnuki, who was captured in Salafi University's foreign student's dormitory.

688

• Acknowledged spending all his money on drugs.^[5]
• Having exhausted all his money, and being too embarrassed to return home broke, he was taking advantage of the loose controls at Salafi University to crash in the foreign student's dormitory, where he had been staying for two or three weeks.
• Said he had never heard of "Crescent Mill guesthouse" before he read the Tribunal's allegations.

680

• The allegation stated: "The detainee was arrested by Pakistani Authorities in Faisalabad, Pakistan, along with several oter living in the same house, who were from Yemen, Saudi Arabia, Palestine, Libya, Russia and Pakistan.^[6]
• To which Hassan replied: "This is true, but let me make this clear. It is a University dorm, so we have international students from all over the world, so it makes sense that we have so many different nationalities."

687

• Apprehended in March 2002 in the Issa guesthouse.^[7]
• Al-Noofayee said that he asked the Tablighi Jamaat to recommend a safer place to stay when the Pakistanis started arresting all Arabs.
• Participated in his Combatant Status Review Tribunal.
• The allegations he faced said "Several of the individuals arrested in the raid on the guesthouse in March 2002 were identified by a senior al Qaida associate." -- but it doesn't assert that al-Noofayee was identified by any al Qaida members.
• One of the justifications for holding al-Noofayee was that he wore a Casio F91W.
• Al-Noofayee said he moved to Pakistan because the tablets he needed to control his chronic back pain were cheaper in Pakistan.

679

• Two of the allegations Ali Tahar faced during his Combatant Status Review Tribunal were^[8][9]:
  • "The senior al Qaida lieutenant ran an al Qaida safe house where a number of al Qaida members were captured."
  • "The Detainee was captured in this safe house."
• Ali Tahar said that the guest house was run by a man named "Issa", who ran it on behalf of the University he had applied for. Ali Tahar said he was captured with thirteen or fourteen other students.

693

• The Summary of Evidence memo prepared for his Combatant Status Review Tribunal stared^[10]
  • "The detainee resided at the Issa safehouse in Faisalabad, Pakistan."
  • Abu Zubayda ^[sic] was the director at the safehouse in Faisalabad, Pakistan as well as one located in Peshawar, Pakistan.
  • Residents of a safehouse in Faisalabad, Pakistan, routinely received endorsement letters from a known al-Qaida operative to attend terrorist training camp.
  • A Khaldan camp weapons trainer was captured at an Abu Zubayda ^[sic] safehouse in Faisalabad, Pakistan.

702

• "The detainee fled Afghanistan following the U.S. bombing campaign and was arrested by Pakistani police in a safehouse in Faisalabad, Pakistan, approximately four months later."^[11]