Talk:Parental Advisory
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
We should make a list of every CD that has a Parental Advisory sticker.
Contents |
[edit] Label's first use
The label was introduced in 1985 after pressure from the Parents Music Resource Center.
Actually, I seem to remember—seeing footage in some documentary or something—of Tipper and/or whomever at a press conference unveiling the "logo"—the distinctive black and white format of the label we know and love today. Previous to that, though, there was no real standard for parental advisories, and the text was usually much less conspicuous—see, for example, the warnings on the covers of "AmeriKKKa's Most Wanted" and "Nasty as They Wanna Be." Does anybody know any more details of when the current-style "explicit lyrics" label came out, or what record it was first used on? —Wiki Wikardo 07:12, 26 May 2006 (UTC)
[edit] Oh, hey, also
Does anybody know when they changed over from "explicit lyrics" to "explicit content?"
I would like to share my opinion about these warning labels. I believe that Tipper Gore and others were wrong to insist on the labels and that these labels should be dropped.
Censorship is wrong and all this happened because Tipper Gore had to be in the spotlight. These labels should be dropped.
I have no clue as to why it was changed. And by the way, this is not censorship. Censorship is preventing things from being viewed, this is just warning people. MalwareSmarts 16:52, 16 August 2007 (UTC)
I don't know when it changed, but I'm pretty sure that it was changed becuase some albums had explicit artwork and not lyrics. My friends call me capn 19:33, 29 September 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Age Level
What's the age level for albums being labeled for explicit lyrics? --PJ Pete
It depends on the state. I think the age level to buy certain albums with labels is 18- but that depends on the state.
Some retailers won't sell offensive material to anyone under 18.
Personally, I think Tipper Gore should have kept quiet. Warning labels don't mean a thing to me. I think these parental advisory labels should be dropped.
here in Oregon its store to store. for example Target doesn't care while Fred Meyer does. MrM 03:58, 11 April 2007 (UTC)
So, if I go to a Target in Oregon, they won't I.D. me, but if I go to a Fred Meyer in Oregon they will? My friends call me capn 01:40, 29 September 2007 (UTC)
[edit] My Chemical Romance
My Chemical Romance are given as an example of an album with only one use of profanity. This is incorrect. "You know what they do to guys like us in prison" and "I'm not okay" are 2 examples of tracks with profanity in them. I'd remove it, but not sure of another example to replace it with. 82.6.67.134 16:06, 13 August 2006 (UTC)Cf
[edit] Green Day
Dookie as well contains explicit lyrics, especially in the song "Longview."
-WalterJid
- I belive I added that in a few weeks ago Maplejet 20:27, 29 January 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Slayer
Seasons in the Abyss is cited as containing no profanity, but I'm pretty sure that's not correct. Listen to Expendable Youth at 2:32.
[edit] Research on the Allure of the Parental Advisory Sticker
The RIAA denies that underage people listen to songs for the profanity, they claim they listen to music for the rythmn and beat. Who would buy something out of spite, that's a complete waste of money.
Personally, I would, if it proved a point (and if I wanted the CD).Dayn 02:18, 17 October 2006 (UTC)
- When the "alternative" trend hit my school (mid-late 90's) it became popular to buy albums with parental advisory stickers because they were seem as being in some way rebellious and a sign that the band was "real" and not just 'pop with guitars'. I don't know of anyone who bought an album they didn't like just for the sticker but it was definitely considered a bonus. Danikat 13:55, 24 February 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Negativland?
Negativland, if Lumberjack Mordam gets folded into Warner Music, may get the Parental Advisory sticker on their albums due to the graphicness and the explicit language on the albums "Escape From Noise", "Helter Stupid", "These Guys Are From England", "Fair Use", "Dispepsi", "Deathsentences...", and "Happy Heroes EP". If they do, then the kids that listen to "The Greatest Taste Around" will have to give up Dispepsi because of the sticker. In fact, maybe Green Day should get their albums labeled and...if the RIAA goes overboard, then we might see "Countdown to Ecstasy" and "Pablo Honey" get the Parental Advisory sticker due to explicit language ("Creep" and "Show Biz Kids", respectively). This needs to stop...probably. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by 66.110.197.20 (talk) 21:38, 1 March 2007 (UTC).
[edit] Renaming
This article must be renamed the label is known as PAL and thats what this article should be titled. 76.109.187.138 18:52, 6 May 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Linkin Park?
It says they only used one instance of offensive words. "Given Up", "Bleed It Out" and "Hands Held High" have curse words.
I haven't heard all the songs, but it mentions "strong instances of profanity", so if it's just words like hell or damn, it may not be considered strong. 71.236.76.120 03:28, 2 June 2007 (UTC)
They said "fuck" 8 times. I think we need to take that out.
[edit] Should we make a list?
I think we should make a list for albums with only 1 strong language (which is "fuck") with the PA Label like Angels And Airwaves's "We Don't Need To Whisper" and albums with lots of f words that has no PA Label like Atreyu and Deftones albums.
Sounds sort of listcrufty. But here's a few for the list is it ever comes around:
- The Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd. First track has the famous profanity.
- The Final Cut by Pink Floyd. The track "Not Now John" has loads of f-words.
But still, it's very listcrufty. MalwareSmarts 16:55, 16 August 2007 (UTC)
Here's some more:
- Pop by U2. It has a number of f-words. MalwareSmarts 18:03, 18 August 2007 (UTC)
- That is a list that will never be complete. Number of reasons.
-
- The label isn't retroactive. There are albums that predate the label that still get pressed today without it.
- This is just the way I remember things, but it seems you could get away with a lot more on a mainstream pop/rock record than you could on a rap record up until the early 00's, when they started putting it on albums regardless of genre. (Pop & Dookie, as 90's rock albums, fall into this category.)
- The version I've heard is each record label has its own rules about how many louse words you can get out before they stamp the advisory on there. Aerosmith's Just Push Play has four instances of fuck, but they're all evaded in the booklet. The Fratellis' Costello Music (which came out in America last year, for reference) has two fucks, one cunt on the record, but only one fuck on the booklet. Perhaps there's an unwritten rule that four is the most you can get away with?
- Between those circumstances, the list would be so massive that it would start to just feel like the authors of the article name-checking their favorite artists that this applies to. (And to be honest, the article already feels that way.) DackAttac (talk) 02:13, 22 February 2008 (UTC)
[edit] Page Avenue
Page Avenue by Story of the Year has no instances of profanity whatsoever, and has the PA sticker. Should that be listed in the article, or are there enough?
[edit] Saudi Arabia?
i am from saudi arabia, i go to the record stores every day, but there is not a single (clean version) album, we do ship PA album, want video or photo prof? —Preceding unsigned comment added by 212.107.116.248 (talk) 10:24, 4 October 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Garbage, Clean "sticker" & More
The iTunes version of "Absolute Garbage" is not "edited" or "clean" or marked as such. However, instead of bearing a parental advisory on the album, it's affixed to the two individual tracks that contain vulgarities (the 'shit' on Why Do You Love Me, as described, but neglected in the article is the 'fuck' on Bleed Like Me).
Also, anything regarding the clean sticker is made up almost entirely of individual research and perception. Clean versions of albums are commercially available, but no one other than Wal-Mart ever wants to stock them. They always can be ordered online. Moreover, there's no such thing as a clean "sticker". Some stores (like FYE), to avoid confusion, put an "Edited" sticker on top of the wrapper, but it's not commonplace. The only obligation the record labels have to such an extent is to make sure the title on the jewel case's upper seal ends with (Edited), (Amended), or (Clean).
Meanwhile, most of the part about iTunes versions of albums being flagged as edited seems inferred. I personally think it's much more likely that a label that signed a Christian band like Relient K wants to drive home the point that the album contains no vulgarities, and checks the "clean" box on the iTunes application, unaware that it doesn't just mean the lyrics are clean, it means they've been changed to be that way. DackAttac (talk) 02:22, 22 February 2008 (UTC)
pa is fucking
